I sent in The Legend of Dragoon and Lunar : Silver Star Story Complete. I got back my Legend of the Dragoon (Non GH because I asked them not to give me it ) shrink wrapped and a letter saying that they couldn't replace Lunar, but will send me a check to reimburse me for it.
Well, I put down the current price of Lunar Silver Star Story was worth to buy it brand new. Where I work, I get a discount. So I will be getting a new PS-2 and some cash back Happy Day!