EverCrest Message Forums
You are not logged in. Login or Register.
Author
Topic: Saturday Morning TV shows...who copyed who?
Azrael Heavenblade
Damn Dirty Godmoder
posted 01-12-2002 03:14:03 PM
Just realized how similar Mighty Morphin Power Rangers are to the first Japanese then US released animated show Voltron. My evidence:

1. Each has five members with five giant robot vehicles that join up to form super-huge giant robot with sword that appears from nowhere.

2. Single villain in huge castle on far-off planet who sends down monsters that grow huge and they have to defeat.

3. Life lessons are taught throughout the show's history.

The differences:
1. Rangers use spiffy yet often unrealistic weapons and flashy martial arts moves to defeat lots of goons that could be taken down by a third-grader with a slingshot while the Lion Force uses blasters on enemy soldiers who fire right back. Edge: Voltron.

2. King Zarkon lives in castle Doom with a freaky witch who crafts special and grotesque monsters for the Lion Force to fight, granting them various abilities. Dumb-looking Rita has odd-looking crony scuplt monsters out of clay, which are then brought to badly-done godzilla suit life and sent down to Earth to bumble around and annoy the rangers for a bit before growing huge and gets it's ass kicked in about a minute when the rangers get their act together. Edge: Voltron.

3. Sidekicks- Rangers: Annoying robot whose only purpose seems to be to alert Rangers when monster baddy is on way. Voltron: Vizier of old king who can actually man the defenses of the castle and occasionally a lion when the time is needed. Edge: Voltron.

4. Popularity- Rangers: Huge merchandise outflow, half-dozen variations in series, everything from lunch boxes to costumes produced. Still on TV today after continuous run from 1995. Voltron: Little merchandising, ran in mid eighties for three years before disappearing, only to reappear in late 1990's for Toonami run, where it has become part of the regular line-up. Edge: Rangers.

Now for some photos: Voltron- Rangers-

Since Voltron was trotted out in 1986, and the Rangers a nearly a decade later, don't you agree that the Rangers are just a poorly done copy of a great yet not as widespread animated series?

"The basic tool for manipulation of reality is the manipulation of words. If you can control the meaning of words, you can control the people who must use them." - Philip K. Dick
Cadga
Quite Insane
posted 01-12-2002 03:16:06 PM
frankly i think your the only person i the world that gives a damn:P
Voltron owns

MMPR sux

dont care who copied who MMPR SUX STILL

thank you

Professional Sinner/Heretic
My mindless dribble
Azrael Heavenblade
Damn Dirty Godmoder
posted 01-12-2002 03:20:10 PM
There was no real point to post, just too hyper to sit still today, looking for weird ideas...I seem to have found one
"The basic tool for manipulation of reality is the manipulation of words. If you can control the meaning of words, you can control the people who must use them." - Philip K. Dick
Rodent King
Stabbed in the Eye
posted 01-12-2002 03:21:45 PM
I don't remeber this Rita person, I remeber Lord, Zidd. Or was it Zork? Some lord with a 'Z' at the begginning of his name.
My inner child is bigger than my outer adult.
Arlander
Pancake
posted 01-12-2002 03:52:02 PM
Lord Zed, I believe. He came after Rita failed to do anything for the 8 billionth time and married her I think, he came complete with new evil putty fighters or whatever they were called. They were stronger than normal evil henchmens, but they had a horrible weakness in dying when you hit the giant Z on thier chest.
Rodent King
Stabbed in the Eye
posted 01-12-2002 03:54:53 PM
Ah yes, the VERY obvious Z in their chest... I always used to count the number of putty things BEFORE the battle and then count the number of times they showed someone hitting their Z's...the numbers were VASTLY different.
My inner child is bigger than my outer adult.
Tegadil
Queen of the Smoofs
posted 01-12-2002 03:56:57 PM
I remember that blue guy in the tube saying to the power rangers "To destroy these new puttys, you must completely destroy them."

For the next hour I stared blankly at the screen trying to figure that out.

Kermitov
Pancake
posted 01-12-2002 03:59:58 PM
The real question is this. If the lions got their asses whooped every time for half an hour before they formed Voltron, and then voltron always killed whatever it was fighting them in one hit then WHY DIDN'T THEY JUST DO THAT IN THE FIRST PLACE?

"Come out of that castle you cowards!"

"FORM VOLTRON feet and legs, arms and body, and I'll form the HEAD blah blah"

"FORM blazing sword!"

SLASH, enemy is dead. Then the rest of the show deals with maintenance of the lions and the party they must have

Maybe Voltron can only be formed through the energy of getting one's ass thoroughly stomped.

Arlander
Pancake
posted 01-12-2002 04:10:31 PM
If everyone used all the power they had right from the start all the bad guys would be dead before they got a chance to look strong. So before joining the cast of the show all bad guys make sure they have a good 10-20 minutes of looking strong before they die in thier contracts.

Thats why.

Comrade Snoota
Communist
Da, Tovarisch!
posted 01-12-2002 04:10:56 PM
G.I. Joe=rox0rz
You smell that? Do you smell that? ...Napalm, son. Nothing else in the world smells like that. I love the smell of napalm in the morning. You know, one time we had a hill bombed for twelve hours. When it was all over I walked up. We didn't find one of 'em, not one stinkin' dink body. The smell, you know that gasoline smell, the whole hill. Smelled like... victory.
Lyinar Ka`Bael
Are you looking at my pine tree again?
posted 01-12-2002 04:35:54 PM
quote:
Azrael/Cthon had this to say about Jimmy Carter:
Just realized how similar Mighty Morphin Power Rangers are to the first Japanese then US released animated show Voltron.

You just realized this?

What's the location of the rock you've been living under?


Lyinar Ka`Bael, Piney Fresh Druidess - Luclin

Ja'Deth Issar Ka'bael
I posted in a title changing thread.
posted 01-12-2002 05:58:59 PM
They're both examples of Sentai (not Hentai). It's a formulaic system of storytelling that goes back as far as the old Ultraman series.

The beauty of Voltron was that it told mature storylines (people getting killed, going bad, rebel uprisings, etc) using the Sentai system to sort of bring things to points.

In fact a lot of pro-Voltron, anti-MMPR folks like the fact that the five lions would try handling things in lion modes without always going to Voltron, and in fact there have been times where one lion's out of commission and they CAN'T go to Voltron mode. The way Power Rangers was written, the question had to be asked why the UberMegaCalamityZord or whatever was even able to be broken down into separate parts. The only time you actually see the heroes use the Zords separately is in the first Power Ranger movie and in that Lightspeed Rescue series.

*shrugs* Voltron kicks booty.

Lyinar's sweetie and don't you forget it!*
"All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die. -Roy Batty
*Also Lyinar's attack panda

sigpic courtesy of This Guy, original modified by me

Gunslinger Moogle
No longer a gimmick
posted 01-12-2002 07:29:15 PM
quote:
Ja'Deth Issar Ka'bael had this to say about (_|_):
They're both examples of Sentai (not Hentai). It's a formulaic system of storytelling that goes back as far as the old Ultraman series.

Would that be something along the lines of a beginning of episode, possibly foreshadowing and such, mid-episode, where the bad d00d puts their plan into action, fight part 1, where they, uh, fight, fight part 2, where they fight in robots, fight part 3, where they combine into one giant robot and kill the person, and end of episode, where anything set up in the beginning of episode is resolved?

...or is it something elseupo? (I'd guess it isn't, seeing as, if I remember Ultraman correctly - and I only saw one or twopo episodes - there weren't any giant combining robots...)




moogle is the 3241727861th binary digit of pi

Disclaimer: I'm just kidding, I love all living things.
The fastest draw in the Crest.
"The Internet is MY critical thinking course." -Maradon
"Gambling for the husband, an abortion for the wife and fireworks for the kids they chose to keep? Fuck you, Disneyland. The Pine Ridge Indian Reservation is the happiest place on Earth." -JooJooFlop

Palador ChibiDragon
Dismembered
posted 01-12-2002 07:42:08 PM
quote:
Check out the big brain on Kermitov!
The real question is this. If the lions got their asses whooped every time for half an hour before they formed Voltron, and then voltron always killed whatever it was fighting them in one hit then WHY DIDN'T THEY JUST DO THAT IN THE FIRST PLACE?

First off, the lions were parked in different areas. Each had a different kind of element powering it, and was parked where it was exposed to that element. So, they had to get them out and together.

Second, the bad guys often had some small fighter ships to take out first. Those the lions were better at fighting. Voltron couldn't fight them as well, and not as many at one time.

Third (as Deth said), sometimes one of the lions would be disabled. So, no Voltron.

Also, Prince Lotor (bad guy) has been known to open fire on the lions WHILE THEY FORMED VOLTRON! Yes, he broke the golden rule of Giant Robot shows. Once, and only once. I think the director took away his dressing room for that, 'cause he never did it again.

I believe in the existance of magic, not because I have seen proof of its existance, but because I refuse to live in a world where it does not exist.
Azrael Heavenblade
Damn Dirty Godmoder
posted 01-12-2002 07:45:19 PM
quote:
Lyinar impressed everyone with:
You just realized this?

What's the location of the rock you've been living under?


Re-realized more-like I haven't watched anything other than news on TV for seven years, so when I tuned into Cartoon Network today and watched a Voltron re-run, then flipped through to MMPR it re-dawned on me My minds been on other things, EQ and gf mainly

"The basic tool for manipulation of reality is the manipulation of words. If you can control the meaning of words, you can control the people who must use them." - Philip K. Dick
Rodent King
Stabbed in the Eye
posted 01-12-2002 07:59:03 PM
I don't know why you guys are comparing MMPR to Voltron when it's obvious that the biggest rip-off between cartoon shows would be Transformers and Beast Wars; I'll just go to their sites to get see more about the two of them and...

....oh...oops.

My inner child is bigger than my outer adult.
Talonus
Loner
posted 01-12-2002 10:02:12 PM
Small note, Voltron is definitely not the...
quote:
first Japanese then US released animated show

Shows like Astroy Boy, Eight Man, Gigantor, and Star Blazers all precluded Voltron. Those're just the shows off the top of me head. Just a little side note.
Gunslinger Moogle
No longer a gimmick
posted 01-12-2002 10:11:23 PM
I'm still curiousupo about what Sentai is exactly...



moogle is the 3241727861th binary digit of pi

Disclaimer: I'm just kidding, I love all living things.
The fastest draw in the Crest.
"The Internet is MY critical thinking course." -Maradon
"Gambling for the husband, an abortion for the wife and fireworks for the kids they chose to keep? Fuck you, Disneyland. The Pine Ridge Indian Reservation is the happiest place on Earth." -JooJooFlop

Sentow, Maybe
Pancake
posted 01-12-2002 10:16:09 PM
quote:
^Moogle-plush-doll^ had this to say about Punky Brewster:
I'm still curiousupo about what Sentai is exactly...

Your initial assumption was correct

Generally speaking, a sentai is a show with a team of superheroes, most often five of them, and each associated with a specific colour and planet/element. They sometimes involve giant robots which can be formed into a single, giant robot (who always, always wins).
As I recall, only live-action shows fit the sentai definition, but shows like Yoroiden Samurai Troopers (aka Ronin Warriors) and Sailor Moon do pretty much the same thing, only without the giant robots.

Once more into the breach, my friends, once more. We'll close the wall with our dead. In peace, nothing so becomes a man as modesty and humility, but when the blast of war blows in our ears, then imitate the action of the tiger, summon up the blood, disguise fair nature with rage and lend the eye a terrible aspect.
OtakuPenguin
Peels like a tangerine, but is juicy like an orange.
posted 01-12-2002 10:26:41 PM
quote:
Talonus stumbled drunkenly to the keyboard and typed:
Small note, Voltron is definitely not the...
[QUOTE]first Japanese then US released animated show

Shows like Astroy Boy, Eight Man, Gigantor, and Star Blazers all precluded Voltron. Those're just the shows off the top of me head. Just a little side note. [/QUOTE]

Speed Racer

..:: This Is The Sound Of Settling ::..
Akiraiu Zenko
Is actually a giddy schoolgirl
posted 01-12-2002 11:31:59 PM
I loved Voltron...haven't seen it in ages...I had the big one that comes apart into lions when I was a kid...He used to fight my big Transformers...
The artist formerly known as Zephyer Kyuukaze.
Kermitov
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 07:16:54 AM
quote:
Palador ChibiDragon had this to say about Cuba:
First off, the lions were parked in different areas. Each had a different kind of element powering it, and was parked where it was exposed to that element. So, they had to get them out and together.

Second, the bad guys often had some small fighter ships to take out first. Those the lions were better at fighting. Voltron couldn't fight them as well, and not as many at one time.

Third (as Deth said), sometimes one of the lions would be disabled. So, no Voltron.

Also, Prince Lotor (bad guy) has been known to open fire on the lions WHILE THEY FORMED VOLTRON! Yes, he broke the golden rule of Giant Robot shows. Once, and only once. I think the director took away his dressing room for that, 'cause he never did it again.



You take me too seriously. Nobody really wants to see 20 minutes of partying/lion maintenance. and of course I do remember when one or more lions was disabled. I remember when that evil prince stole blue lion and kidnapped the princess.

I just find it funny, in other shows also, not just Voltron when I find myself screaming out the obvious solution to a bunch of bumbling characters completely ignoring the fact that they are bumbling as a time killer

Yes I do know what formula means.

Kermitov
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 07:18:38 AM
quote:
Sentow had this to say about Tron:
Your initial assumption was correct

Generally speaking, a sentai is a show with a team of superheroes, most often five of them, and each associated with a specific colour and planet/element. They sometimes involve giant robots which can be formed into a single, giant robot (who always, always wins).
As I recall, only live-action shows fit the sentai definition, but shows like Yoroiden Samurai Troopers (aka Ronin Warriors) and Sailor Moon do pretty much the same thing, only without the giant robots.


Did someone say "Captain Planet" yet?

same thing right?

Il Buono
You see, in this world there's two kinds of people, my friend.
posted 01-13-2002 07:28:47 AM
You people all need jobs or something.

Especially Deth.

"Those with loaded guns, and those who dig. You dig."
KaLourin
Illanae's Stooge!
posted 01-13-2002 09:47:10 AM
quote:
Rodent King had this to say about Optimus Prime:
I don't know why you guys are comparing MMPR to Voltron when it's obvious that the biggest rip-off between cartoon shows would be Transformers and Beast Wars; I'll just go to their sites to get see more about the two of them and...

....oh...oops.


*sends his cat after the rodent king. Thou shalt not take the Transformers name in vain, unless you speak of the Robots in Disguise series. That one hurts..*

Dont make me slap you so hard your bucket spins around, and around,and stops sideways,thus confusing you, and making you run about London wearing your bucket, a g-string, and carrying a stick,smacking the ground while yelling "MAGICALLY DELICIOUS! MAGICALLY FUCKING DELICIOUS!"- {Tal} to Mortious
Hebrew 9:3- 'And the Lord said unto me, "Dude, there isn't a K in covenant."' - Snoota

This beer drops trou and fucks your mouth with pure hoppy goodness. - Karnaj
UBT
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 10:50:46 AM
Well, since the Transformers came out a little before Voltron I would have to say the MMPR came out first. Transformers started out as MMPR vehicles bought by Hasbro, and thus created a cartoon to sell these vehicles. The entire Transformer universe at that time was strictly American. Voltron came after the Transformers, making Voltron, if anything, a copy of MMPR. Specially when they came out with Voltron 2, something around 20 vehicles that created the new Voltron.
Here is a picture of the vehicle Voltron...
This public message has been brought to you by UBT

[ 01-13-2002: Message edited by: Uniformed BoyToy ]

Palador ChibiDragon
Dismembered
posted 01-13-2002 11:14:40 AM
quote:
Uniformed BoyToy had this to say about Tron:
Specially when they came out with Voltron 2, something around 20 vehicles that created the new Voltron.

15 Vehicles. Five on each team of Air, Ground, and Sea.

Each 5 vehicle team could also link their vehicles together into a super vehicle.

Yes, I had the large versions of BOTH Voltron toys at one time. But neither of them was as cool as my SDF-1 (but my cat chewed the tips off of the main cannon).

I believe in the existance of magic, not because I have seen proof of its existance, but because I refuse to live in a world where it does not exist.
Ja'Deth Issar Ka'bael
I posted in a title changing thread.
posted 01-13-2002 11:19:35 AM
quote:
KaLourin DthBlayde had this to say about Jimmy Carter:
*sends his cat after the rodent king. Thou shalt not take the Transformers name in vain, unless you speak of the Robots in Disguise series. That one hurts..*

KaLourin is my hero.

Lyinar's sweetie and don't you forget it!*
"All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die. -Roy Batty
*Also Lyinar's attack panda

sigpic courtesy of This Guy, original modified by me

UBT
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 11:32:57 AM
Well, it was a guessof the number of cars and I was close hehe. I knew it was more than 5 anyways.
Lyinar Ka`Bael
Are you looking at my pine tree again?
posted 01-13-2002 03:38:41 PM
...BoyToy...

Voltron is from the 80s. Transformers is from the 80s.

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers is from the 90s

How the hell could that come out first?


Lyinar Ka`Bael, Piney Fresh Druidess - Luclin

UBT
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 04:59:02 PM
MMPR is from the early 80's in JAPAN. Transformers were originally the vehicles from MMPR, hence why most of them had actual seats, because power rangers were supposed to sit there. Learn more about the Transformers and then come talk.
Ja'Deth Issar Ka'bael
I posted in a title changing thread.
posted 01-13-2002 05:23:36 PM
Power Rangers assorted "Zord" vehicles came from a variety of series. Any time you saw a different set of ranger costumes, it was a different series. This was a topic way back when I first joined the boards. Yeesh.

Power Rangers is older than its appearance in the United States. I'd like to see some official dates as to when the source shows for Power Rangers come out before I buy into the notion that Power Rangers came out before Transformers. Doing live action shows can be more expensive than doing animation, and after the success of shows like Macross (Robotech in the US), one would think that they would have stuck to a formula that works.

By the way, for those of you bringing up cartoons like Eight Man, Astro-Boy, etc. There's a difference between Anime superhero cartoons and anime Sentai. Sentai was also, by the way, not just a medium of live action. It reflects a sub-genre. In Japan, success is based on the team rather than the individual generally, and they favor certain notions like harmony of the elements. Thus Sentai reflects achievement over diversity through unity, rather than doing it solo (Wolverine of X-Men fame, believe it or not, is considerably less popular in Japan because of his loner attitude). Even in series like Macross/Robotech, the hero seldom succeeded alone (Rick had Max and the Skull Squadron).

Sentai is marked, usually, by Voltron/MMPR qualities. Multiple pilots in vehicles that are powerful alone and link up to become even more powerful. While the element vehicles often have some elemental connection (Steel, Wood, Wind, Fire, Water generally), that's not a universal trait. Good Sentai (from a storytelling element) uses the sentai team traits as a metaphor to progress the story, and villains generally are intelligent or cunning. Neither of those elements crops up in the Power Rangers series, and thus is generally considered "bad" sentai.

Lyinar's sweetie and don't you forget it!*
"All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die. -Roy Batty
*Also Lyinar's attack panda

sigpic courtesy of This Guy, original modified by me

Lyinar Ka`Bael
Are you looking at my pine tree again?
posted 01-13-2002 05:41:02 PM
The live action series that's widely known and that spurred spin-offs and movies is from the 90s. What was the history in Japan? Was there a cartoon or another live action series that came out before Fox made the one with American teens popular?


Lyinar Ka`Bael, Piney Fresh Druidess - Luclin

MechaCrash
Pancake
posted 01-13-2002 10:26:43 PM
quote:
Lyinar had this to say about Optimus Prime:
The live action series that's widely known and that spurred spin-offs and movies is from the 90s. What was the history in Japan? Was there a cartoon or another live action series that came out before Fox made the one with American teens popular?

There was never one with American teenagers in it in Japan. Saban took chunks of the footage, sliced them apart, and spliced in their own stuff. They also took completely unrelated series and threaded them together, Robotech style.

pLaY 2 kRuSh!
Vorago
A completely different kind of Buckethead
posted 01-14-2002 06:36:44 AM
I always wondered why Rita had in insist on attacking the one place on Earth with the power rangers, and not just attack everywhere ELSE

Well, that and I wonder why if she could throw her staff down to Earth, why they didn't just bombbard the town with fireballs or something

And how did she get it back?

Gydyon
Yes, I am a lawyer. No you can't sue them for that. Shut up, or I'll have your legs broken.
posted 01-14-2002 07:22:18 AM
quote:
Zephyer had this to say about Robocop:
I loved Voltron...haven't seen it in ages...I had the big one that comes apart into lions when I was a kid...He used to fight my big Transformers...

So did I. And so did I!

Gydyon
Evercrest Lawyer

Thinking about your posts
(and billing you for it) since 2001

Squire Twitch
Pancake
posted 01-14-2002 07:33:08 AM
quote:
Ja'Deth Issar Ka'bael impressed everyone with:
*A bunch of shit I read in the first post, and skipped in the second*

SHUT THE FUCK UP!

Sorry, that was my initial reaction. My second, and more thought out reaction is this..

If we admit you are smarter than us, and all knowing, and better worded, will you please SHUT THE FUCK UP???

I mean really, Every time I see you post, its just to show off that you know more about some obscure cultural differance between tribes of prairie dogs on the sarengeti, or the differance in color shades between The partridge family bus, and the camoflage pattern of the french foriegn legion.

You're like Cliff Clavin, without the charm, or humor.


If yer offended, who fucking cares? If anybody else is offended, lighten the fuck up.

My parents just came back from a planet where the dominant lifeform had no bilateral symmetry, and all I got was this stupid F-Shirt
All times are US/Eastern
Hop To: